Ethical Considerations for Attorneys: Responding to Online Reviews

Ethical Considerations for Attorneys: Responding to Online Reviews

We all know that positive reviews are some of our best referrals.
They can be great for the firm, as they provide real feedback from clients and
help drive business. It follows that if your firm wants return customers and
referrals, you need to respond to your reviews, both positive and negative.

Why Should We Respond to Online Reviews?

Responding to reviews is important to your firm because it provides
the opportunity for positive engagement with past and future clients. Engaging
briefly and professionally with each review helps to do two important things:

1. It establishes connection with clients, creating a bridge to
future business and referrals.

2. It increases the possibility that issues can be resolved (and a
bad review removed).

In recent surveys, over 70% of consumers expected a response to
online reviews, with most wanting to see a response within 24 hours. Over 80%
said they would consider editing or removing a negative review based upon the
response. We recommend that your firm have policies and procedures in place for
responding to reviews, particularly negative ones. 

How Do We Ethically Respond to Reviews?

There have been cases where a response to a legal review catches the
attention of the state bar – you don’t want that. By encouraging positive
conversation in your responses, you can substantially improve your service and

Here are our suggestions:

  • Respond to all online reviews, but responses
    should be standard and brief. 
  • For negative reviews, don’t admit having made a
    “terrible mistake,” but do apologize and attempt to make things right. 
  • Do not try to win an argument.
  • Don’t discuss details of cases or reveal
    personal client information. 

We recommend using the THEM method as a guideline for responding to
negative reviews:

Timing: Respond within 24 hours

Honesty: Acknowledge bad experience and offer resolution

Empathy: Address the client’s point of view

Message: The goal is resolution, keep it positive

Your response to a negative review can turn a negative into a
positive for both your customer and firm.

Three Additional Ethical Considerations for Legal Reviews:

Asking for reviews:

When asking for reviews, do not tell the client what to write on reviews or (although it may be legal) reward clients for positive reviews. 

For bankruptcy lawyers:

Bankruptcy is a personal matter and some clients may not be willing
to discuss their case in a public forum where their name would be associated
with their situation. For these, sites like & Avvo allow for
anonymous client reviews.

Posting testimonials on your firm’s website:

While most bars allow client testimonials, it is important to
address your state’s ethics rules, restrictions and disclaimers regarding
attorney advertising and testimonials. If there are no special requirements in
your state, it is still advisable to use a disclaimer on your site that
addresses the possibility of unjustified expectations or misleading

2019-08-06 10:00:40

Schedule an appointment

Check out Charles ’s calendar to schedule an appointment where you can discuss marketing solutions tailored to your firm’s needs.


See what other attorneys said about Charles

  • “Charlie: Thanks for your prompt, informative information; you’ve always been great at getting back to me ASAP with answers to my questions! Thanks again! Kim Denise Morton”

    ~ Morton Family Law

    “Charles DeFeo presents a simple, high quality and cost effective solution for attorney advertising! If you are thinking Attorney advertising is too Expensive for your firm - Think again! - Rob Schall, Cooper & Schall, PC”

    ~ Cooper & Schall, PC

  • “Charles DeFeo has been our professional Martindale-Hubbell consultant for many years. At all times he has demonstrated his concern for our Law Firm’s well-being and success, a great part due to his efforts on our behalf. -JFW III, Esq.”

    ~ Joseph Wusinich

    “Charles DeFeo is an outstanding Sales Manager who gets the job done for his clients.  He has serviced our account for many years and we love him.  I would highly recommend him.”

    ~ Edward Sweeney

  • “Charles DeFeo has worked with my business since its inception. He is always attentive to the needs of my business and responds immediately to any concerns. The website has been a great asset to my business.”

    ~ Barbara Stein

    “Charlie is very knowledgeable about the product, the profession and the marketplace.  He gives excellent customer service.  I have always felt that he has our best interests in mind when discussing options for legal advertising.”

    ~ George Donze

Contact Us

To get started now, please let us know how Charles can reach you.