5 Mistakes With Lead Follow Up and How to Fix Them

5 Mistakes With Lead Follow Up and How to Fix Them

I am passionate about this topic as I really believe that this is an area a lot of firms can improve to sign up more cases without spending any additional dollars.  I am going to be throwing a lot of statistics out and you might get tired of looking at graphs and numbers, but as it relates to lead follow up I think these numbers are important because most people I talk to do not have a good idea on what these results are within their own firm.

I am going to start with what is the biggest issue firms have with lead follow up and that’s following up on a lead immediately.  This study on the left from MIT used the barometer of 60 seconds to initially reach out to a potential client.  That time frame is a lot of times difficult to accomplish so what I would tell you is to make 5 minutes your gold standard.  Reaching out to a lead within the first 5 minutes you receive the information should take priority over pretty much anything else your firm is doing at that time.  You can see on the chart below just how quickly your chance of connecting with a lead drops after that 5-minute mark. 

Another fact that is very true is that you cannot litigate or
settle a case that you don’t have.  So,
make sure that following up immediately with a web inquiry, chat lead, a call
that your answering service took and even the leads from your 3rd
party lead generators takes precedence over anything else.  It is difficult to fathom what 238% increase
of your chance of signing a qualified client over your competitor could mean
for your firm, but I am willing to bet that number would make a sizable impact
for any firm. Assumptions are dangerous. 
I say that because whether people like to admit it or not, I see too
many firms make the assumption that just because a claimant reached out to your
firm, they only want to sign with you.  A
more accurate assumption to make is that if a claimant has reached out to your
firm, they have also reached out to at least two other firms as well. 

This is especially true for website contact firms and chat
leads.  Consumers who go down the path of
researching law firms online are the majority of the time submitting their
information on multiple sites, so this is where that increase in sign up
percentage on first contact really comes into play.

This next item is something that comes up a lot with me when
I am on a presentation of Captorra and are reviewing our own automated follow
up tool.  People will ask “how do we not
piss off the potential client by contacting them to much?”  My answer always is, don’t worry about that
and let them tell you that they are not interested in your services.  The chart on the right is a study conducted
with 500 consumers across the country for varying services. 

What immediately jumps out to me is that 2 of the top 3
complaints consumers have about submitting a web inquiry is that they never got
contacted back or that the response took too long.  The alternative to following up too much is
that they just end up signing with another firm.  Even if the potential client doesn’t have a
case, your competition is still able to get in touch with them first and is
able to plant the seed of marketing for how they can help them and their family
and friends in the future. 

Now that we have talked about how you shouldn’t really be concerned about following up too often, let’s talk about what that should like.  The numbers on the right are from a report across 5,000 leads in 2016.  The absolute minimum number of attempts you should be making before giving up on that lead is 6. 

The numerous follow up attempts needed to reach a potential client does bring me to something I want to mention that is extremely important for a firm looking to scale.  Your firm should really look to dedicate a staff member or department for following up with leads.  In my experience, attorneys and legal staff are not great at following up with potential clients and I completely understand why.  Your day as a legal staff member within a firm is prioritized by your current case load.  Whether people like to admit it or not, their ability to quickly call a new lead, or to make that 6th attempt to reach out to a lead can be hindered by other priorities in their day.  Not only that, it takes a completely different mentality to “smile and dial”.  Most people within a firm can successfully take a direct phone call from a potential client and go through an intake, but that same person isn’t necessarily equipped to successfully jump on a lead right away or call them for the 6th time which is what is needed to convert them into a signed client. 

is also important to make sure you are not simply relying on phone calls and
voicemails to connect with your leads. 
People today just simply do not answer the phone.  We as consumers are trained to wait and see
what the person calling wants before deciding how to proceed.  Along with utilizing these different methods,
it is also important to provide valuable content to the claimant with each
touch point.  Whether you’re leaving a
voicemail, sending an email or text, make sure that each time you reach out you
are providing something different of value to that potential client.  That could be stressing how time is of the essence
or stating your firm’s successful track record with their type of case, it is
extremely important to make sure your messaging isn’t stale and that there is
something there to prompt them to contact you back versus a competitor.

To take this a step further, I want to specifically focus on
the importance of leveraging text messaging as part of your follow up
process.  Here are some more numbers from
a study from last year that show how much more effective text messaging is over

Most firms I talk to today have gone down the path of
utilizing some type of email communication as follow up, even it is
manual.  Most groups however have not
gotten on the text messaging bandwagon and I believe this is extremely
detrimental in today’s market.  The fact
that 98% of text messages are opened versus 22% of emails shows how much more
effective text messaging is. The last fact regarding time to open is extremely
important as well.  3 minutes for text
messages versus an average of 384 minutes for emails can easily make the
difference of you connecting with your next client versus another firm.  Even if a potential client does end up opening
your email, it most likely is going to take them much longer to respond than if
it was a text message.  Given this
information, it is extremely important to implement text messaging as part of
your process.  The excuse of “my client
base doesn’t have smartphones or won’t respond to text messaging” is a very
lazy and dangerous excuse. 

I want to talk about following up at different times of the
day.  The numbers below are probably not
all that surprising to a lot of you, but I see specific staff making the
mistake of following up at the same time with a potential client repeatedly. 

I believe it is there way of easily remembering that they
need to follow up again with a claimant which is a great mentality to have but
doing so at the same time every day is a big waste of your time.  If someone can’t answer the phone or get back
to you at 10:30 AM because they are sitting at work on a Monday, it is probable
that they can’t do it on Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday or Friday either.  So really try to track when you are making
these attempts and stagger them at different times for each one.  On top of this, I would highly recommend
making your follow up attempts after the initial reach out early in the day and
later in the afternoon.  Before 9:00 AM
and after 4:00 or 5:00 PM tend to by the time that the average person can take
the time to discuss their case with you. 
If at possible, try to even have someone at your firm making follow up
attempts on the weekend. 

The last main point I want to cover is the need to track all
this data that we have been discussing. 
It is impossible for you to know what is and isn’t working and make
changes based on that if you don’t have the analytics to utilize.  It is critical that you know when leads are
coming into your firm, on average how quickly you are making that first initial
call and how many attempts your staff is making after that.  The report below lets me know exactly when a
lead came into my firm, how many attempts have been made to reach the potential
client, when those attempts were made and by who.  I can look at this and know how often leads
are being contacted right away and how often we are exhausting efforts with
that 6th attempt versus letting leads sit in the system. 

Everything we have talked about today does not cost you any
extra dollars out of your pocket to implement, it just takes discipline and

If you are not utilizing a specific lead follow up tool like
Captorra, it is still critical that you are able to track how well or how
poorly your firm is at following up with your web leads. After reading through
this, you may think “this is a way too much to fix for my firm”.  The good news is that if you fix even just
one of these mistakes it would make a huge difference for your practice and
most of them don’t cost you a dime.  Quit
trying to outspend your problem with more marketing and look internally to sign
more cases!

2019-10-22 10:00:59

Schedule an appointment

Check out Charles ’s calendar to schedule an appointment where you can discuss marketing solutions tailored to your firm’s needs.


See what other attorneys said about Charles

  • “Charlie: Thanks for your prompt, informative information; you’ve always been great at getting back to me ASAP with answers to my questions! Thanks again! Kim Denise Morton”

    ~ Morton Family Law

    “Charles DeFeo presents a simple, high quality and cost effective solution for attorney advertising! If you are thinking Attorney advertising is too Expensive for your firm - Think again! - Rob Schall, Cooper & Schall, PC”

    ~ Cooper & Schall, PC

  • “Charles DeFeo has been our professional Martindale-Hubbell consultant for many years. At all times he has demonstrated his concern for our Law Firm’s well-being and success, a great part due to his efforts on our behalf. -JFW III, Esq.”

    ~ Joseph Wusinich

    “Charles DeFeo is an outstanding Sales Manager who gets the job done for his clients.  He has serviced our account for many years and we love him.  I would highly recommend him.”

    ~ Edward Sweeney

  • “Charles DeFeo has worked with my business since its inception. He is always attentive to the needs of my business and responds immediately to any concerns. The website has been a great asset to my business.”

    ~ Barbara Stein

    “Charlie is very knowledgeable about the product, the profession and the marketplace.  He gives excellent customer service.  I have always felt that he has our best interests in mind when discussing options for legal advertising.”

    ~ George Donze

Contact Us

To get started now, please let us know how Charles can reach you.